What Makes a Good Charcoal Grill?

The best barbecue experience merits the right grill. With many options in the market, most outdoor BBQ enthusiasts love a good charcoal grill. However, deciding between a kettle or a barrel is a tricky decision to make, unless you know what you want. There are several types of charcoal grills, but the majority fit between kettle or barrel grills. How then do you choose the best one for your backyard? Here is the ultimate guide to help you decide.

Editorial Choice

Sale
Char-Griller E56720 AKORN Kamado Charcoal Grill,...
1,478 Reviews
Char-Griller E56720 AKORN Kamado Charcoal Grill,...
  • 314 Square inches of primary cooking space, warming rack 133 Square inches for a total of 447 Square inches
  • Assembled Dimensions: 45" L x 31" W x 47" H | Weight: 97.0 lb
  • Insulated design means more heat uses less charcoal and less airflow means insulated heat for juicy meat
  • Cooking surface is cast iron, body is constructed of 22 gauge Steel, exterior finish is powder coated Steel, interior finish is porcelain coated steel
Product
Best of The Best
Char-Griller E56720 AKORN Kamado Charcoal Grill,...
Best Budget Pick
Weber 121020 Go-Anywhere Charcoal...
Easy To Move
Char-Griller E1515 Patio Pro Charcoal Grill, Black
Material
Iron
Porcelain-Coated Cast Iron
Steel
Manufacturer
Char-Griller
Weber
Char-Griller
Weight
89 Pounds
14.5 Pounds
50 Pounds
Front or Side Handle
Easily Fold
Fixed
Wooden & Fixed
Rating
Reviews
1,478 Reviews
2,766 Reviews
1,943 Reviews
Pros
Need Less Charcoal
Large Space Fit For 4 Medium Steaks
Easy Dump Ash Pan Help To Easy Clean Up
Prime
Con
High Price
Low Quality Handle
Grilling Surface is Small
Best of The Best
Product
Char-Griller E56720 AKORN Kamado Charcoal Grill,...
Material
Iron
Manufacturer
Char-Griller
Weight
89 Pounds
Front or Side Handle
Easily Fold
Rating
Reviews
1,478 Reviews
Pros
Need Less Charcoal
Prime
Con
High Price
Best Budget Pick
Product
Weber 121020 Go-Anywhere Charcoal...
Material
Porcelain-Coated Cast Iron
Manufacturer
Weber
Weight
14.5 Pounds
Front or Side Handle
Fixed
Rating
Reviews
2,766 Reviews
Pros
Large Space Fit For 4 Medium Steaks
Prime
Con
Low Quality Handle
Easy To Move
Product
Char-Griller E1515 Patio Pro Charcoal Grill, Black
Material
Steel
Manufacturer
Char-Griller
Weight
50 Pounds
Front or Side Handle
Wooden & Fixed
Rating
Reviews
1,943 Reviews
Pros
Easy Dump Ash Pan Help To Easy Clean Up
Prime
Con
Grilling Surface is Small

Buying Guide Charcoal Grill:

Barrel grills

The Barrel grills appear like a steel barrel sliced into two equal half. The top half acts as the cover, while the bottom half holds the charcoal chamber. Then, the grill has a chimney attached on the top of the barrel to control smoke, while the vents allow for circulation when the lid is closed.

With the barrel grill, you enjoy more flexibility and capacity to hold your meat, since it is much larger than a kettle grill. They, therefore, befit grills for at-home grilling, events, commercial and mobile food-service applications. If you want an extra-large barrel grill, then you can find one that allows you to use wood logs in addition to charcoal, wood chunks and chips, for an even better taste. It is why barrel grills are particularly common for commercial use. Other than that, the barrel grill works great during the warm seasons, especially summer, because they have a low capability of retaining heat.

Given the sizes of the barrel grills, you can expect them to get costly, sometimes as high as $1,000. The best bit is that you get value for your money because it has more notable features than the kettle grills which are very simplistic as will be discussed below. Overall, the barrel grills are the perfect choice for slow cooking and smoking meats for large gatherings, parties, and events.

Kettle grills

The kettle grill takes a much smaller size than a barrel grill. You would quickly consider this grill for at-home grilling purposes, more especially to feed small gatherings of people. It even requires less fuel to operate at higher temperatures, which for most people, is a win.

The charcoal grill is portable and has a round or oval shape to it. The defined bowl is what holds your coals, not to mention, allows for the retention of much of their heat. People will often prefer this charcoal grills because they have simpler grilling tasks with shorter cook times as compared to the barrel grills.

Given its sizes, the kettle grills are more economical than the barrel grills. If you want a simple grill that is relatively cheap and still gets the job done, then the kettle grill should be your choice.

The better option?

Choosing the best charcoal grill smoker combo is an overwhelming decision. Before you get swayed back and forth on which grill to choose, ensure you have consideration for some of the following factors:

Size of the grill – if you need a bigger grill, especially for the cooking surface, then the barrel is best.

Temperature control – given your geographical location and the amount of temperature control you want to exercise when grilling your meat, your choice changes. The lid of your grill has a major role in temperature control. The walls and egg-shaped design make the kettle grills better in temperature control

Cooking Uses – if you want to indulge in heavy grilling, then the better option would be the barrel grill.

Cost – how much are you willing to spend on a charcoal grill? Ultimately, the bigger the grill, the more money you have to spend on it. Further, the more you pay, the better quality you get, regarding a sturdy construction, and a grill that produces a better flavor.

Some final tips:

Take your time when choosing a charcoal grill, buy the best product you can afford, and follow the above-mentioned buying guide and you will be rewarded with years of good service and enjoyable grilling experience. For further information, you can check Globo Surf. They have written a comprehensive article on how to choose a weber grill.

Leave a Comment